Honeypot links...


GM+ Member Britt just wrote the below in the community (and coined the term "honeypot links")...

"I knew there would be fake clicks, but there could be a lot. I’ll know soon because I set up the system today and from tomorrow, I’ll know."

After a few recent "viral giveaways" I noticed something weird with my email engagement.

The little "follow me on social" buttons above my signature all recieved the exact same number of clicks.

Weird, right?

When I looked into it, the clickers were all addresses from brands like McKinsey, Blackrock etc.

If you've ever seen this, this is what's happening.

Big brands have email security which clicks every link in your email to check it for spam and malicious content before the end recipient gets to see it.

Your ESP logs it as a click, even though it's not a real person.

Which throws off your tracking.

It looks good in the ESP, but the time on site and engagement post click is seconds.

On the surface, it looks liek you're doing well, but really nothing is actually happening with those clicks and there's no genuine engagement.

You don't even know if the real person is actually reading anything you send.

Here's the thing.

Cleaning this with a normal re-engagement campaign that has a "click this to stay subbed" isn't going to work because these systems click EVERY link.

So I needed to come up with a better system.

I adapted the normal re-engagement campaignt to focus on a specific, on-page action rather than a click.

Here's an overview of how it works...

  1. I include a secret, hidden link in the emails only a bot will click
  2. That tags them as a bot
  3. There's a new sequence that starts (similar to a re-engagement email)
  4. The user has to resubmit their email to stay subbed (not based on simple clicks)

I've done a more detailed breakdown in the GM+ Community you. can see by joining here.

I dropped that hidden link in an email yesterday and it got 232 link clicks.

That's 232 clicks per link my emails were getting not from people, but from bots.

So, if you had 5 links, your ESP would record 1160 clicks.

You can see how this would throw off your tracking, right?

In 7 days I'll know if these people are engaged or if they're simple bots, and I'll have a cleaner list at the end of it.

And I'll once again get a better idea of actual link clicks for engagement.

If you're getting suspect clicks and a regular re-engagement sequence isn't cutting it, I recommend trying this.

And if you want to see a video of how I set it up, check out the GM+ Community here.

Pete "Bot killer" Boyle

Vagrants, Vagabonds, and Villains Ltd, Unit 16535, 13 Freeland Park, Wareham Road, Poole, Dorset BH16 6FA
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Growth Models

I've spent ~10 years helping digital brands grow. I share what I know and what I'm experimenting with in this newsletter.

Read more from Growth Models

I've been trying to get the $1 Product Challenge working through YouTube ads as a self-liquidating offer. When I'm working something like this out, I keep a long-form document where I drop my... ... thoughts...... observations...... experiments and results... ... writing it all out helps me format my thoughts and understand what I'm actually doing. I've then got a cool doc that forms the base of a course or workshop once I've cracked the code. Anyway, I'm consdering adding these documents...

"How much content do I need to launch a new offer?" I recently had this convo with a member of GM+ who's launching something new. They were asking whether they needed... A full website with multiple pages, content, proof etc A simple funnel ... to land new clients. For years, I was setting up the former. I had this long-arse list of pages, content etc that was "needed" to launch a new offer. Home page, about page, offer page, contact page, testimonial page, 4 pieces of launch blog content,...

I've worked with so many people stuck in a self-defeating loop. They think they need an audience to sell their offer… But they can’t grow an audience because they have nothing focused to sell. So they just post random crap, hoping someone, somewhere, bites. And when no one engages or buys... They blame it on “not having an audience.” It’s backwards. Look, I collect cash from people who have never seen my beautiful face every single day. This morning, I spent $24 on a course from someone I've...